Crime & Safety

Third Victim Dead in Shooting Rampage Outside Philadelphia That Killed a Holmdel Resident

Monica Shay died Thursday. She and her husband Paul Shay own a house in Douglass Township where they and three others were shot on Saturday.

A third victim has died in a shooting rampage Saturday outside Philadelphia, in which a former Holmdel resident was killed.

Monica Shay, 58, died Thursday, said Paul Hoffman, Deputy Coroner, Lehigh Valley County Coroner's Office. An autopsy will be conducted Friday to determine the cause.

Shay was shot in the head at a Renninger Road, Gilbertsville, Douglass Township house she owned with her husband Paul Shay, 64.

Find out what's happening in Holmdel-Hazletwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

On Sunday, Montgomery County District Attorney Risa Vetri Ferman and Douglass Township Police Chief Barry L. Templin Jr. identified the victims in the shooting as Paul Shay and his wife Monica, Joseph Shay, Kathryn Erdmann and her son, Gregory.

Joseph Shay, 43, of Yarmouth, MA, and New York, NY, and Gregory, 2, were shot in the head and killed. Joseph Shay was a 1986 graduate of Holmdel High School and came back to Holmdel to visit classmates in town.

Find out what's happening in Holmdel-Hazletwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

According to a report by the Associated Press, Joseph Shay is Paul Shay's nephew. 

Kathryn Erdmann, 37, of Fall River, MA, was also shot in the head. The AP described Erdmann as Joseph Shay's girlfriend.

"Despite their extensive injuries, (Erdmann) and (Paul Shay) were able to speak to investigators," Montgomery County First Assistant District Attorney Kevin Steele said in a news release on Monday. "Both are expected to survive."

The Montgomery County Coroner’s Office last week conducted autopsies on Joseph Shay and Gregory and concluded both victims died of gunshot wounds to the head.

The alleged shooter, Mark Richard Geisenheyner, led police on a manhunt after the shootings through Monday. That day, after a six-hour standoff with police, a SWAT team shot and killed Geisenheyner in a Trainer, Delaware County house, Ferman said.

The shootings could be the result of a plan concocted nearly three months ago by Geisenheyner, who sought revenge against Paul Shay, she said.

"We are investigating reports that (Geisenheyner) was involved in an insurance fraud scheme with one of the victims, and that was the motive for the murder," Ferman said on Monday.

Statements made by “multiple people” to the district attorney’s office uncover Geisenheyner’s plan to kill Paul Shay.

"The killer told people from the time he got out of prison 15 months ago that he had been involved in a scheme with Paul Shay and was seeking revenge against him," said Ferman.


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here

To request removal of your name from an arrest report, submit these required items to arrestreports@patch.com.